Voice of the Commonwealth - The Global Influencer

Voice of the Commonwealth - The Global Influencer

Ties between racism and refugee policy…how Haitian migrants are treated

HAITI – The first protected category of the United Nations refugee convention is race. The 1951 convention defines a refugee as a person who is outside their country of residence or nationality “owing to well-founded fear of being persecuted for reasons of race, religion, nationality, membership of a particular social group or political opinion.”

Racism negatively affects the lives of Haitians at home and abroad. Yet Haitian migrants today are rarely deemed eligible for asylum.

This requires us to think about racism and the treatment of refugees transnationally. Brazil-led UN peacekeeping operations and the outsourcing of U.S. immigration control to Latin America further complicates asylum for Haitians.

Why is race being so central to the UN’s refugee convention? Probably because much of it was drafted by former Jewish refugees from the Holocaust and their allies. The drafters added two important clauses.

The first one, Article 3, stipulates non-discrimination by the receiving countries (by “race, religion, and country of origin”). The second is the principle of non-refoulement that prohibits countries from returning migrants to dangerous conditions back home.

Other considerations that determined the final scope of the convention include the breakup of empires and wealthy countries’ continued racial barriers to immigration.

Haiti, colonialism and empires

Much of the racism toward Haitians comes from abroad.

In the late 1700s, Haitian revolutionaries expelled French colonizers and abolished slavery. A few years later, Haiti provided refuge for victims of enslavement and colonialism elsewhere.

But France and other countries demanded reparations for their lost “property,” meaning human beings. Haiti had to pay this debt throughout the 20th century.

From 1915 to 1934, the United States military occupied Haiti, with lasting social and political consequences. In 1937, Dominican dictator Rafael Trujillo ordered the slaughter of thousands of Haitians living near the border.

From the 1950s through the 1980s, the U.S. supported the Duvalier dictatorship. Since then, there has been nearly continuous foreign intervention in Haiti’s politics.

Facing economic and political instability, many Haitians go abroad to improve life for themselves and their relatives back home. For Haitians, the lines between diaspora, economic migrant and refugee are often blurred. But legally, these categories can make all the difference.

U.S. sent Haitians back home

Starting in 1981, the U.S. adopted a policy of interdicting and processing Haitian migrants at sea. This effectively established a loophole and allowed them to circumvent the principle of non-refoulement and send Haitians back home.

Following this precedent, wealthy countries today increasingly started to put immigration on “remote control” — in other words, they control immigration from a distance, in international waters and third countries’ territories.

There is now a broader outsourcing of security and human rights as Latin American countries have been put in charge of receiving refugees and managing UN peacekeeping missions.

Brazilians in Haiti, Haitians in Brazil

In 2004, democratically elected Haitian President Jean Bertrand Aristide was ousted for the second time, probably with the help of the U. S. Canada, France, the U.S. and other major players quickly recognized the regime that replaced him. Later that year, Haiti received a peacekeeping mission, the United Nations Stabilization Mission in Haiti, known as MINUSTAH.

Until 2017, MINUSTAH’s multinational military force was run by Brazilian generals, with much meddling from the U.S., Canada and France.

In order to depoliticize the situation, these generals were instructed to deal with the problem of “gangs” by force. Urban neighborhoods, where gangs supposedly resided, were precisely the bases of Aristide’s political support.

In a book about the military commanders of MINUSTAH, these generals called the low-income neighborhoods of Port-au-Prince “favelas,” or shantytowns, suggesting the problem was one of policing.

Another term they use is pacificação. This is not just a translation of peacekeeping. Historically, pacificação was a euphemism for the colonization of Indigenous Peoples.

It’s also a reference to the work of Rio de Janeiro’s police units called Unidades da Policia Pacificadora. There was an ongoing exchange of security management personnel, ideas and practices between Port-au-Prince and Rio de Janeiro during that period.

After the massive 2010 earthquake that displaced hundreds of thousands of survivors, Brazilian authorities became concerned about Haitians arriving in their country.

Latest news

Singapore makes donation to Afghan earthquake relief

Singapore (CU)_ In response to the devastation caused by the fatal earthquake in Afghanistan, the Singapore government will donate US$50,000 to the Singapore Red...

Related news

416,000 jobs in Latin America and The Caribbean supported by travellers

CARIBBEAN - The way people travel has changed forever. Now, people are more flexible about where they live and work and take longer trips....

EU sets corporate board quotas for women by mid-2026

Paris, France (CU)_ According to the lawmakers, the European Union (EU) negotiators agreed to the group's first-ever quota for women on corporate boards, in...

Dominica PM makes last ditch plea for inclusion of all countries at Summit of Americas

DOMENICAN REPUBLIC - Dominica’s Prime Minister, Roosevelt Skerrit, has made a personal appeal for all countries to be invited to the Ninth Summit of...

Kodak Black Celebrates Haitian Mother’s Day With $20K Cash

HAITI - Kodak Black is in the spirit of giving. He honored his aunts on Haitian Mother’s Day by giving them all $20,000 each. This doesn’t...

JAMAICA – The murder tally in Jamaica now stands at 594 as at May 27. 

This represents a seven per cent increase year on year. Which is a shame for this beautiful country as its largest economic dependency is...

‘National freeze’ on handgun ownership to take effect in autumn

OTTAWA (CU)_Just a week ago, nineteen students and two students were fatally shot at Robb Elementary School in Uvalde, Texas, United States, triggering passionate...

Yukon’s border set to open for first time since COVID  

DAWSON CITY, Yukon (CU)_The ferry has started to operate and the highway has been cleared of snow. Yukon’s tourism industry is abuzz with anticipation...

Royal couple visits Ukrainian church in Canada as hundreds more surrender in Mariupol

OTTAWA (CU)_The Prince of Wales and the Duchess of Cornwall are currently on a three-day tour in Canada to mark the Queen's Platinum Jubilee...


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Latest News

Singapore makes donation to Afghan earthquake relief

Singapore (CU)_ In response to the devastation caused by the fatal earthquake in Afghanistan, the Singapore government will donate US$50,000 to the Singapore Red...

Whither Sri Lanka…what ailst thou?

By: Niranjan de Silva Deva Aditya Malignant self destructive mistrust of SriLanka by SriLankans can only be mitigated by the creation of a UN Special...

900,000 Malaysians have relocated to Singapore!

Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia (CU)_ Several economic sectors of the country have improved after the Covid-19 pandemic, but the labor crisis in Malaysia remains unaddressed...

Mauritius emphasizes strategic significance of GCC nations

Port Louis, Mauritius (CU)_ The Mauritius Tourism Promotion Authority (MTPA) has announced its long-term goals and commitment to establish deeper economic relationships with GCC...

Intra-Commonwealth trade to reach $20 trillion over the next five years!

London, United Kingdom (CU)_ British prime minister Boris Johnson has praised the benefits of current relationships between Commonwealth nations and highlighted that intra-community trade...

How to handle your LGBTQ+ child when they come out!

Sydney, Australia (CU)_ Coming out may be an extremely emotional and personal process for many, including the kid and the parent. According to research,...

US honors Bangladesh’s resilience.

Dhaka, Bangladesh (CU)_ Peter Hass, ambassador of the United States to Bangladesh, stated that the United States honors a nation like Bangladesh that has...

Biotechnology can boost inclusive development in Nigeria, Agency head

Abuja, Nigeria (CU)_ According to Prof. Abdullahi Mustapha, Director-General of the National Biotechnology Development Agency (NABDA), biotechnology has the capacity to expedite inclusive national...

Try this magical Ayurvedic herb for overall well-being!

Kochi, India (CU)_ Giloy is a popular Ayurvedic plant well-known for its therapeutic properties. Giloy is native to India, although it is also cultivated...

New entrants to the Oscar Academy!

Mumbai, India (CU)_ The Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences has welcomed 397 new members this year, including actors Kajol and Suriya, filmmakers...

Government must prioritize children’s rights!

Male, Maldives (CU)_ First Lady Fazna Ahmed has asserted that the rights of children should be the utmost priority of government officials. She remarked...

India is the third most common birthplace of Australians!

Mumbai, India (CU)_ According to 2021 statistics, Hinduism in Australia has increased by 55.3% as India has surpassed China and New Zealand to become...