USA (Commonwealth Union)_ Following the resounding victory in the 2024 US presidential election, President-elect Donald Trump has reignited a divisive debate on immigration with his proposal to end birthright citizenship. This move, if enacted, would overturn a practice that has been part of the United States for over 150 years. Additionally, the implications of this policy are far-reaching, particularly for Indian immigrants and their families, who make up a significant portion of the US immigrant population.
Also read: Chennai-born Indian American teen wins Miss India USA 2024 title!
The Birthright citizenship and its controversy
Birthright citizenship, enshrined in the US Constitution’s 14th Amendment, guarantees citizenship to any child born on US soil, regardless of the immigration status of their parents. It has been a cornerstone of American immigration policy since the Reconstruction era, ensuring that children born in the US automatically gain citizenship, a right that was reaffirmed by the Supreme Court’s ruling in United States v. Wong Kim Ark in 1898.
However, Trump has repeatedly expressed his dissatisfaction with this policy, labeling it ridiculous and claiming it encourages birth tourism, a practice in which women from foreign countries travel to the US to give birth, securing citizenship for their children before returning home. In a recent interview, Trump emphasized, “We’re going to have to get it changed… But we have to end it.” Though he raised the issue during his first term, no concrete actions were taken. Now, with his second term, the proposal is back on the table, with Trump pledging to end birthright citizenship by January 20, 2025.
Also read: Meet the first Indian-origin appointed to Reserve Bank of Australia board
How it affects Indian immigrants?
The potential end of birthright citizenship has sent shockwaves through the immigrant community, particularly among Indian Americans, who represent one of the fastest-growing and most economically dynamic immigrant groups in the US. According to the US Census Bureau’s 2022 American Community Survey, there are more than 5.2 million Indian Americans, with roughly 34% born in the US. These individuals stand to be directly affected by Trump’s proposal.
Indian immigrants, particularly those on temporary work visas such as H-1B, have relied on birthright citizenship as a key incentive for migrating to the US. The prospect of ending this guarantee raises concerns for families who have settled in the US with the expectation that their children will have access to the benefits of American citizenship. These families now face the prospect of uncertain futures for their children, who may be left without a clear path to citizenship or a stable national identity.
Additionally, the implications extend beyond individual families. India is one of the top countries of origin for US immigrants, with many individuals coming to the US for education, employment, or entrepreneurial opportunities. The promise of birthright citizenship for children born in the US has long been a significant motivator for Indian families to relocate. If Trump’s proposal succeeds, it may discourage future generations of Indian immigrants from considering the US as a destination, potentially shifting migration patterns to countries with more favorable immigration policies.
Also read: Forbes 30 Under 30 2025: Meet the 8 Indian-origin AI innovators set to transform the tech world
How it impacts the Indian-American workforce?
Indian Americans have made significant contributions to the US economy, particularly in sectors such as technology, healthcare, and academia. Many Indian immigrants enter the US through programs like the H-1B visa, which has been under scrutiny during Trump’s first term for allegedly disadvantaging American workers. Ending birthright citizenship could exacerbate these concerns, leading to further challenges for Indian professionals who have invested years of their careers in the US.
Additionally, a reduction in the availability of skilled workers could have long-term effects on the US economy, particularly in industries that rely heavily on immigrant talent. The healthcare sector, for instance, which depends on Indian professionals, could see a shortage of qualified workers if immigration policies become more restrictive. Indian students, who make up a significant portion of the international student population in the US, may also reconsider their educational and career aspirations in the US, potentially opting for countries with more accessible immigration pathways.
Growing opposition from Indian Americans
Indian-American advocacy groups have strongly opposed the proposal, arguing that ending birthright citizenship would undermine a core American value and disrupt the lives of millions of immigrants. Accordingly, organizations like the Indian American Impact Fund and South Asian Americans Leading Together (SAALT) have emphasized the contributions of Indian immigrants to the US economy and society. They contend that the 14th Amendment’s guarantee of birthright citizenship is a fundamental right that should not be tampered with. In India, the proposal has sparked anxiety among families with relatives in the US. Many wonder whether the American Dream, a symbol of opportunity and prosperity, remains achievable for Indians. Additionally, the Indian government, which has made efforts to strengthen ties with the Indian diaspora, may soon face diplomatic pressure to address these concerns.
A shift in global immigration patterns
If Trump’s plan gain traction, it could lead to a shift in global immigration patterns. Countries like Canada, Australia, and the United Kingdom, which offer more balanced immigration systems, may become more attractive to Indian families seeking stability and opportunity. This could result in a brain drain from the US, as skilled Indian professionals and students look elsewhere for their futures.
The future of birthright citizenship
The debate over birthright citizenship is not just a political issue; it has deep personal and economic implications for Indian immigrants in the US. Trump’s proposal leaves millions of Indian families uncertain about their future in America. Whether the policy is implemented remains to be seen, but its potential impact on the US immigrant landscape and the Indian-American community could be profound. As the US approaches a new presidential term, all eyes will be on how this issue unfolds and what it means for the future of immigration in America.
