Healthcare (Commonwealth Union) – The idea that a pleasant smell can help you remember things has long appealed to fans of aromatherapy. But new research from the University of California, Los Angeles suggests the reality is more complicated, and that how new a scent feels may count for more than the scent itself.
The study, published in the journal Frontiers in Aging Neuroscience, found that adults who completed memory tasks in a room filled with lavender essential oil did not do significantly better overall than those in an unscented room. This was true for both young and older participants.
Yet one pattern stood out. Older adults who first met the scent at the beginning of the learning process remembered more than those who met it later. Younger adults showed no such difference.
Background
Smell and memory have a well-known link. A whiff of a familiar fragrance can bring a long-forgotten moment rushing back, and that has fed claims that aromatherapy could improve recall or even slow cognitive decline. Scientists, however, are still working out how the brain ties experiences to odors, and the evidence so far has been mixed.
The work also touches on a growing area of Alzheimer’s research. Neuroscientist Stephanie Leal, the study’s corresponding author, explained that earlier studies have connected a declining sense of smell in later life with Alzheimer’s disease, prompting interest in using changes in smell as an early warning sign. Her team wanted to explore whether scent cues might influence memory even when a person’s sense of smell is not working as well as it once did.
How the experiment worked
Leal and colleagues from Rice University recruited healthy young and older volunteers with no signs of Alzheimer’s. Everyone first took a standard smell test to measure their baseline ability to detect odors. Half the participants then entered a room where a diffuser had been releasing lavender oil, while the rest entered a room with no added scent. Researchers picked lavender because it is widely familiar and can be seen as pleasant by some people and unpleasant by others.
Anyone who saw the first set in the scented room saw the second in the unscented room, and the reverse was also true.
After a delay, volunteers were shown images that were identical to, slightly altered from, or completely different from what they had seen. A hair dryer that had been red might now appear blue. This allowed the team to measure both general memory, which is recognizing a type of object, and detail memory, which is recalling specifics such as color.
What they found
As expected, older adults had more trouble remembering details. What surprised the researchers was that the lavender made no difference to either age group. Leal said the team was puzzled by this, given earlier work suggesting that smell can enhance memory.
The timing result offered a clue. Older adults who smelled lavender during the first learning phase recalled objects more accurately than those who smelled it during the second. In addition, older participants who found the scent pleasant, and those who began the study with less impairment in their sense of smell, remembered details better.
The researchers interpret this as a sign that novelty helps bind a scent to an experience, particularly with age. In other words, it may be the newness of the smell, rather than its type, that gives memory a lift.
What it means
Leal said that supporting memory in older people requires looking beyond whether something helps or hurts and considering when and how it is experienced. She noted that novelty is a major part of learning as we age, and that learning in a rich, stimulating setting may make picking up new information easier.
Overall, the team concluded that scent may work better as a strategic tool than as a general memory enhancer, and that fresh sensory experiences could be valuable for memory as people grow older.The research was funded by the National Science Foundation, the BrightFocus Foundation, the Brain and Behavior Research Foundation and the Alzheimer’s Association.



