India (Commonwealth Union)_ Recent rankings by TasteAtlas, which designated chicken tikka masala as a British delicacy in its list of “50 Best Chicken Dishes Around the World,” have ignited a spirited debate among Indian food enthusiasts and global culinary experts alike. The rich, flavorful sauce of chicken tikka masala has long been celebrated, but the question of its true origins continues to spark controversy.
Also read: Over 24,000 Indian-Americans register for “Modi & US: Progress Together”
The culinary controversy
TasteAtlas’s decision to label chicken tikka masala as a British dish has puzzled many and reignited discussions about the dish’s origins. This list also highlights other Indian chicken dishes, including butter chicken, chicken tikka, Chicken 65, and tandoori chicken, further complicating the narrative. Critics argue that the British designation of chicken tikka masala disregards its deep connections to South Asian cuisine. Accordingly, one social media user expressed skepticism, questioning how a dish with a name so evidently tied to Indian cuisine could be considered British. Another user pointed out that while the dish may have evolved in the United Kingdom, its cultural roots remain firmly South Asian. These comments reflect a broader debate about whether chicken tikka masala should be classified as British or Indian.
Also read: Bharat Ramamurti – Kamala Harris’s secret weapon in the battle for economic reform
The origin of chicken tikka masala
The origins of chicken tikka masala have always remained the subject of considerable debate. The term tikka refers to bite-sized pieces of meat, a concept introduced to the Indian subcontinent by the Mughal emperor Babur. Chicken tikka, a popular dish in northern India and Pakistan, is marinated chicken pieces cooked in a tandoor. Chicken tikka masala, characterized by its creamy tomato-based sauce, has a more contested history. The precise moment of its creation remains unclear, but its emergence in the UK is often attributed to the significant migration of South Asians in the mid-20th century. The popularity of curry in Britain dates back to the Victorian era, when dishes inspired by Indian cuisine were adapted to British tastes. Additionally, the rise of Bangladeshi-owned curry houses in the United Kingdom further influenced the evolution of Indian dishes, possibly leading to the creation of chicken tikka masala.
The British connection
One prominent claim suggests that the dish was first created by Ali Ahmed Aslam, a Pakistani-origin chef in Scotland. According to Aslam’s account, in 1972 he invented chicken tikka masala at his Glasgow restaurant, Shish Mahal. The story goes that a customer found his chicken tikka too dry, prompting Aslam to add a creamy tomato sauce to the dish. According to a 2001 media report, this version quickly gained popularity across Britain, with Aslam’s creation even surpassing fish and chips in popularity. Additionally, Robin Cook, the UK’s former foreign minister, famously declared chicken tikka masala a “true British national dish,” illustrating how British cuisine has absorbed and adapted external influences.
Other claims
Despite the Glasgow claim, some argue that chicken tikka masala is a variation of butter chicken, a dish with origins in India. Butter chicken, or murgh makhani, was reportedly created by Kundan Lal Jaggi and Kundan Lal Gujral in the 1950s after they fled to India during the Partition. Their story parallels Aslam’s, suggesting that the dish’s roots may indeed be Indian. According to Monish Gujral, head of the Moti Mahal restaurant chain, his grandfather had served chicken tikka masala as early as 1947, adding another layer to the dish’s complex history. Another theory attributes the dish to Bangladeshi chefs who migrated to the United Kingdom in the 1960s. According to the Multicultural Handbook of Food, Nutrition and Dietetics, these chefs developed chicken tikka masala according to British tastes, further complicating the dish’s origin story.
A continuing debate
With multiple claims to the dish’s nativity, the argument over chicken tikka masala’s true birthplace is still continuing without a definite solution. Food writer Leena Trivedi-Grenier suggests that the dish might have been independently created by several individuals simultaneously. She also denied the concept that chicken tikka masala was crafted solely to appease British tastes. As the debate continues, perhaps it is best to appreciate the dish for its global popularity and its ability to transcend cultural and geographical boundaries. Chicken tikka masala’s enduring appeal is a testament to its universal flavor and widespread acceptance.
Conclusion
In response to the ongoing culinary debate, global and Indian foodies have also suggested incorporating other Indian dishes like Kadhai Chicken or Chicken Ghee Roast into rankings to highlight the richness of Indian cuisine. This debate highlights ongoing discussions about cultural ownership and authenticity in global food discourse. Ultimately, whether chicken tikka masala is British, Indian, or a fusion of both, its widespread popularity and beloved status in the United Kingdom and beyond underscore its importance in the culinary world. Regardless of its origins, the dish continues to bring joy to millions and serves as a symbol of the dynamic interplay between cultural influences in food.
