Voice of the Commonwealth - The Global Influencer

Voice of the Commonwealth - The Global Influencer

Yorgen Fenech’s vast wealth is flight risk, judge says in human rights case

Yorgen Fenech’s considerable assets in several countries, his access to cryptocurrencies and his influential contacts abroad were just a few of the reasons given by a judge in her decision, earlier this week, to dismiss a claimed breach of human rights by the man accused of the murder of Daphne Caruana Galizia.

In her extensively referenced 60-page judgement rejecting Fenech’s claim, Madam Justice Miriam Hayman disagreed with Fenech’s defence, which claimed Maltese law did not mention the risk of public disorder as a consideration on bail.

“This argument is entirely mistaken, even from the simple fact that Malta adheres to the Convention [European Convention on Human Rights], with the inevitability that case law and notions, as developed by the European Court, are also applicable to us in the case at issue.”

Stressing that she did not want to be interpreted as acting as a “third-tier Court” with respect to the rejections of Fenech’s many bail applications, the judge said her role was to see whether there was a breach of some requisite under ordinary law, the Constitution, or the European Convention on Human Rights which would justify the applicant’s complaint.

The former Tumas magnate is accused of having masterminded the 2017 assassination of journalist Daphne Caruana Galizia, who revealed the existence of his offshore company in Dubai – 17 Black. After her death, the Daphne Project connected the company to the offshore Panama companies opened by former chief of staff Keith Schembri and former energy minister Konrad Mizzi. Fenech was a shareholder in Electrogas, the €200 million plant at Delimara that powers Malta with natural gas.

In her decision, the judge said Fenech was previously granted police bail upon his arrest, with port and airport controls placed on a heightened state of alert. Fenech had received disclosure of the evidence against him immediately after arrest when he requested a Presidential pardon. Both police inspectors Keith Arnaud and Inspector Kurt Zahra had testified about chats in which Fenech considered emigrating to Miami. Other international connections which the accused had with Dubai were still under investigation.

“I have no hesitation in saying that this reason, which formed the basis of the decrees attacked, is something the accused had brought upon himself with the texts he wrote,” she said on the fear of Fenech absconding.

The judge ruled that she “didn’t have the slightest doubt” that Fenech, faced with Melvin Theuma’s presidential pardon, had gone into “drive-and-panic mode, with the clear intention to put distance between him and these islands. This emerges with crystal-like clarity from all the texts which were exhibited… which clearly show the mental state of the applicant at that time.”

The judge pointed to Fenech’s attempt to leave Malta on his yacht “with the weak excuse that he was going to deliver it to a shipyard in Sicily,” but also highlighted the “frantic search for flights, private aircraft, the research on vehicles (by his brother), the no-document rental of a house etc.”

These arrangements had been made in a short period of time, “in an almost erratic and panicky manner, with the help of his brother Franco and ‘Uncle Ray’ to leave these islands before, as Fenech himself says, they blame everything on him.”

The accelerated and unplanned nature of the plans to take the yacht to Sicily, ostensibly for maintenance, “and all the manoeuvres he carried out not to return to our country doesn’t leave much room for further interpretation by the Criminal courts.”

The prosecution’s fear of Fenech absconding was also borne out by his discussion of the possibility of moving to the United States, where he had also been looking at schools for his children, added the judge.

Absconding was a real possibility in view of Fenech’s vast wealth, said the court, adding that his text messages left no doubt about his “easy availability of liquid assets.”

The judge pointed out that although Fenech’s assets “should be struck by freezing orders” from both the murder and money laundering proceedings against him, no evidence had been exhibited that the orders were still in force, also observing that Fenech was not prevented from using other assets which the chats indicated that he had invested abroad.

“It is apparent from these same chats that he can obtain financial assistance from various members of his family, who like him have considerable wealth. Similarly, it emerged that he has access to cryptocurrency with which he bought weapons, no less. Money for the purchase of grenades and cyanide! In short, Fenech has a not-negligible access to assets which could reinforce the fear of absconding.”

The judge observed that in their decisions denying him bail, the courts had also taken Fenech’s multiple connections to influential foreign figures into consideration.

She noted that the evidence showed that Fenech’s mobile phone was found to contain an image of the pardon granted to Melvin Theuma, “that he received, no less, from the Chief of Staff Keith Schembri.”

“It is hard to escape the ease with which Fenech had access to certain information which surely never should have been in his possession.”

The investigation appeared to still be active and appeared to involve a substantial number of people, noted the court. “The more people involved, the greater the fear of evidence being compromised. And the greater the privileged position of these people and the ease with which they obtain certain information also the greater the fear of compromise.”

The Commissioner of Police had publicly declared, and had exhibited a note to this effect, that everyone involved in the murder had been charged, said the court. “Why the Commissioner made this declaration and the circumstances in which it was made are unknown to this court. What is certain is that today the in genere [magisterial inquiry] into this murder is still ongoing, which means that there are persons possibly involved in this crime who have not been identified or who could be subject to compromise.”

Acknowledging that the length of the investigations could be seen as a factor against Fenech’s continued detention, the judge however, also quoted cases where the European Court had accepted that complex investigations can merit an exception to the rights of the person being investigated.

Ruling that Fenech had not suffered any breach of his constitutional rights, the court dismissed the case with costs to be borne by the plaintiff. State Advocate Chris Soler and lawyer Maurizio Cordina represented the State in the proceedings.

Lawyers Gianluca Caruana Curran, Marion Camilleri and Charles Mercieca appeared for Fenech. Lawyers Therese Comodini Cachia and Jason Azzopardi represented the Caruana Galizia family.

Latest news

Calls to import coal through aggregating agency

KOLKATA (CU)_Over the recent months, there has been an increase power generated through coal in India, both domestic and imported. As of Friday, power...

Related news

Zelenskyy opens the Cannes Film Festival, connects war and film

Cannes, France (CU)_ The 75th Cannes Film Festival began with a focus on Russia's invasion of Ukraine and a live satellite video message from...

The fall of Mariupol is just around the corner

(CU)_Since Russia decided to invade neighbouring Ukraine in late-February, capturing Mariupol has been one of the major goals of the Russian forces. While hundreds...

No solutions to food and fuel crisis until Ukraine and Russia return to market, says UN Chief

London, United Kingdom (CU)_ UN Secretary General Antonio Guterres stated that he was seeking negotiations to reintroduce Ukraine and Russian agriculture and fertilizer production...


GLOBAL - Having completed the Ramadan Umrah rites as prescribed by the Holy Prophet Mohammad (SAW), the first batch of Lagos State Ramadan Umrah (Lesser...

Evidence found linking Suspect to Madeleine McCann’s disappearance

GLOBAL - Investigators continuing to try to explain what happened to three-year-old Madeleine McCann in Portugal 15 years ago claim to have found evidence...

Pope Francis says he isn’t ready to travel to Kyiv ‘yet’

MILAN (CU)_Over the past few weeks, British Prime Minister Boris Johnson, European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen, UN Secretary-General António Guterres and several...

UN chief ‘shocked’ by proximity of Russian attacks

(CU)_The Secretary-General of the United Nations, Antonio Guterres, visited Ukraine on Thursday (28 April), just a couple of days after his meeting with Russian...

Elon Musk’s Twitter Takeover will bring these changes!

California, USA (CU)_ Twitter has accepted Elon Musk's $44 billion acquisition proposal, and the transaction has officially been completed. Even though the transaction is...


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Latest News

Calls to import coal through aggregating agency

KOLKATA (CU)_Over the recent months, there has been an increase power generated through coal in India, both domestic and imported. As of Friday, power...

Over 6000 employees required for Singapore Changi Airport!

            Singapore (CU)_ Changi Airport Group (CAG) has announced the launch of one of the largest recruiting campaigns in Singapore's aviation sector, with more...

One of Australia’s most anticipated mineral exploration targets is about to be drilled

PERTH (CU)_Chalice Mining has finally received long-awaited approvals to work inside a state forest in Western Australia, which would mean one of Australia’s most...

President Hichilema’s vision for Zambia’s vital mining sector

CAPE TOWN (CU)_Zambia's President Hakainde Hichilema recently participated in the annual African Mining Indaba that was held in Cape Town, South Africa. The Zambian...

A clear signal of intent after breaking the trust of Aboriginal Australians

PERTH (CU)_Back in May 2020, Rio Tinto destroyed a 46,000-year-old Aboriginal site in the expansion of… an iron ore mine in Western Australia. Although the...

A marathon trip designed to signal Beijing’s broader ambitions in the Pacific

HONIARA (CU)_Over the recent weeks, China’s growing influence in the Indo-Pacific has come under the spotlight following a controversial security agreement that was signed...

Queen to perform at Platinum Jubilee concert alongside Sir Elton John and Alicia Keys

LONDON (CU)_In less than two weeks, Queen Elizabeth will be celebrating her 70th anniversary of taking the throne. A series of events are scheduled...

Popular Indian Americans are investing in the US T20 cricket league!

California, USA (CU)_ According to recent media reports, popular Indian American business executives including Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella and Adobe CEO Shantanu Narayen are...

Suhana Khan’s 22nd birthday bash was with the Archies squad!

Mumbai, India (CU)_ Suhana Khan turned 22 this year. The popular star kid celebrated her 22nd birthday with ‘The Archies’ team filled with enjoyment....

Singapore envoy lauds Bangladesh’s electricity and energy sectors

Dhaka, Bangladesh (CU)_ The energy industry of Bangladesh is booming. Recently, Bangladesh began building the 2.4-gigawatt (GW) Rooppur Nuclear Power Plant, which is anticipated...

25 years after the murder, Metropolitan Police still has ‘much to do’

LONDON (CU)_Back in April 1993, Stephen Lawrence, a black British teenager from Plumstead, southeast London, was waiting for a bus in Well Hall Road,...

The transgender community welcomes Pakistan’s Transgender Endowment Fund Bill 2022

Islamabad, Pakistan (CU)_ The transgender community and civil society have lauded the government of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa for passing Pakistan's Transgender Endowment Fund Bill 2022....